Warning From Former Scout: 5 First Round 2023 NFL Draft Busts
The game film does not lie, and it says these five draft prospects should be avoided by teams in the first-round of the 2023 NFL Draft.
No. 1 Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida
First Round Mock Grade: Fifth-Round
NFL Mock Draft Database Consensus: First-Round No. 4 overall
Proof of evaluation: (2021) LSU (2022) Utah, Kentucky, Tennessee, Georgia, and FSU
Bust Probability: High
Trey Lance all over again.
Richardson is an athlete first and a quarterback second.
A number of Gators fans have commented they didn’t think he was ready to declare.
Richardson’s skill set does not translate well to the NFL for four other reasons:
-Tends to hold the ball too long (Avg. NFL QB release 2.5 seconds)
-Erratic downfield ball placement (53.8% completion percentage last season)
-Tends to throw dangerous passes
-Doesn’t do well under pressure (pass rush and game situations)
No. 2 Will Levis, QB, Kentucky
First Round Mock Grade: Seventh-Round
NFL Mock Draft Database Consensus: First Round No. 7 overall
Proof of evaluation: (2021) Georgia, South Carolina, Missouri (2022) Florida, Mississippi State, and Tennessee
Bust Probability: High
Besides being deathly afraid of the site of milk, liking to put mayo in his coffee, and eating bananas without peeling them, Levis has bust spray painted all over his game film.
There are four kisses of death for NFL QBs, and Levis shows all four of these characteristics
-Downfield tunnel vision that doesn’t allow him to feel the rush or see opposing defensive backs
-Looks tentative throwing
-Hard stares intended receiver
-Erratic downfield ball placement (46-25 touchdown-to-interception ratio)
No. 3 Will Anderson Jr., EDGE, Alabama
First Round Mock Grade: Second-Round
NFL Mock Draft Database Consensus: First-Round No. 3 overall
Proof of evaluation: (2021) Ole Miss, Texas A&M, Georgia (2022) Tennessee, Texas, Arkansas, and LSU
Bust Probability: High
This isn’t Micah Parsons. Anderson (40-yard-dash 4.6) doesn’t have Parsons’ speed (4.39).
Where does he line up?
That’s the first question at 243 pounds.
The other four main issues with Anderson:
-Lacks want and takes plays off
-Lacks flexibility to make quick adjustments
-Depends on bull-rush and stalls out too easily
-Lack of desire defending the run
No. 4 Quentin Johnston, WR, TCU
First Round Mock Grade: Third-Round
NFL Mock Draft Database Consensus: First-Round No. 12 overall
Proof of evaluation: (2021) Oklahoma, Kansas State, West Virginia (2022) Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas
Bust Probability: High
Johnston is no Randy Moss.
The big problem is he is not a natural pass catcher.
Johnston had one catch for 13 yards in the National Championship, and he was held to four or fewer catches in 10/13 games in 2022.
There are three additional issues:
-Noticeable rigidity that causes trouble adjusting to the ball
-Limited catch radius
-Below average high pointing deep passes
No. 5 Myles Murphy, EDGE, Clemson
First Round Mock Grade: Third-Round
NFL Mock Draft Database Consensus: First Round No. 17 overall
Proof of evaluation: (2021) Georgia, Pitt, Iowa State (2022) NC State, Wake Forest, and Syracuse
Bust Probability: High
Murphy looked soft 70% of the time on this 2022 game film.
There are other six issues also surrounding this prospect:
-Struggled winning the edge
-Sputtering motor
-Lacks flexibility to make quick adjustments
-Limited usage of pass rush moves
-Disinterest defending the run
-Missed tackles
Daniel Kelly is a former NFL Scout with the New York Jets. He was hired on the regime which featured Bill Parcells, Bill Belichick, Scott Pioli, Mike Tannenbaum, and Dick Haley. He currently writes for Sports Illustrated New York Jets and he is the Editor-in-Chief for First Round Mock. For more information about him visit his website at whateverittakesbook.com. He can be followed on Twitter @firstroundmock.
Featured Articles
Former NFL Scout: Caleb Williams is a Bust
Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch every game of USC QB Caleb Williams in 2023 embedded into this article.
NFL High-Risk Pick: Heisman Trophy Winner QB Jayden Daniels
Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch LSU QB Jayden Daniels in 12 games from the 2023 season embedded in this article.
Oregon QB Bo Nix Puts Up First-Round Game Film
Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 24 games of Oregon QB Bo Nix embedded into this article and the two attached articles within this article.
Shedeur Sanders Presents ‘2Legendary’ Podcast
Reading Time: 2 minutesFirst Round Mock's Victoria Jonach looks into Colorado Buffaloes QB Shedeur Sanders and his new '2Legendary' podcast.
Anthony Richardson is a Bust According to Former NFL Scout
Reading Time: 3 minutesGame film projects Florida quarterback Anthony Richardson as a fifth-round NFL Draft value.
Will Levis is a Bust According to Former NFL Scout
Reading Time: 3 minutesFind out why Kentucky quarterback Will Levis has no chance in the NFL.
Former NFL Scout Calls C.J. Stroud “Generational Talent”
Reading Time: 3 minutesC.J. Stroud has all the tools to be an NFL franchise quarterback in the 2023 NFL Draft.
Travis Hunter Inks Exciting NIL Deal with United Airlines
Reading Time: 2 minutesFirst Round Mock's Victoria Jonach looks into Colorado wide receiver Travis Hunter's new NIL deal with United Airlines.
Ashton Jeanty: WOW
Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 10 games of Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty during the 2023 season embedded into this article.