(Photo by Tom Pennington/Getty Images)
(Photo by Tom Pennington/Getty Images)

The Next Big Thing? Caleb Williams, QB, USC

Reading Time: 3 minutes

First Round Mock’s William Yanish gives USC quarterback (QB) Caleb Williams one of the lowest grades anyone has dared to give him – – based on the game film.

They’ve always said that the NFL is a copycat league.

Every time something works, the whole league tries the same approach.

It was true with 49ers’ QB Joe Montana and the West-Coast Offense that took the league by storm some years ago. Now, we are all the way up to the QB of the Kansas City Chiefs, Patrick Mahomes and his playground style of football.

Many have tried. When it truly comes down to it, a copy just isn’t quite as sharp as the original.

Caleb Mahomes?

Mahomes can do things that only Mahomes can do…

His style is unique to him as an individual.

There’s all the off-platform throws, and the playground drops that feature launching the football without setting his feet.

It’s simply a whole different brand of football.

Whether it’s a fad, or the new standard, it will stay around as long as Mahomes is having success doing it.

For sure, it will stay around until the next big thing.

Williams is the next in line to try to continue this “Mahomes approach” to the game and many have drawn the comparison…

He stands at 6-foot-1 and 215 pounds, and he is another transfer portal veteran as he followed his head coach from the University of Oklahoma to USC.

The Yanish Report

Adequate arm, not overly strong. Accuracy and ball placement are okay on short and intermediate routes. Deep ball placement and accuracy is bad. Mechanics and footwork have gone out the window. Off-platform throws are inaccurate. Gets rattled. Tons of tipped passes. Clutches the ball too long. Tunnel vision. Stares down receivers. Good mobility. Great speed and acceleration. Climbs and dances through the pocket. Not great in the red zone. Shies away from contact.

For the win

#Generational

#TopQBProspect

#TheNextPatrickMahomes

#Superstar

There are no shortage of tags placed on Williams.

The thing of it is – – these tags are simply not true.

The loss of wide receiver Jordan Addison (drafted by the Vikings) will affect him, and if his running back Austin Jones isn’t there to bail him out, Williams isn’t special.

In my humble opinion, Williams spent more time painting his fingernails than he did trying to defeat Utah in the PAC-12 Championship.

Looking at his background, he puts up big numbers, but he just can’t win the big games. USC finished off 2022 with losses in the PAC-12 Championship game vs Utah and a Cotton Bowl loss to Tulane.

Williams is not the QB that I would build a team around. It takes heart to win.

That is the name of the game.

My BIG three questions

1. Will he be able to finally stop Utah and win the PAC-12 Championship?

2. Can he improve his work ethic to take the next step as a QB?

3. Will he be able to overcome the end-of-season losses?

How Williams stacked up and game film reviewed

My Draft Value: Third-Round (and I’m being generous)

Game Film Evidence

Oklahoma 2021 (Jersey No. 13)

Baylor ‘21

Oregon ‘21

Oklahoma State ‘21

USC 2022 (Jersey No. 13)

UCLA ‘22

Notre Dame ‘22

Utah ‘22

Utah PAC-12 Championship ‘22

Tulane ’22 Cotton Bowl

William Yanish III is a life long football fan. He’s from the little town of Crawford, Colorado. Along the way, he’s lived in Dutch Harbor, Alaska and Brookings, Oregon. Quarterback Joe Montana was his idol growing up. A little bit of CTE from life’s adventures killed his dreams as a football player. Now, he is an aspiring writer and Draft Analyst at FirstRoundMock.com. He’s a fanatic with a dream, which is coming true.

Featured Articles

Cam Ward 2025 NFL Draft QB1

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch Miami QB Cam Ward in 13 games from the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Shedeur Sanders Undraftable Free Agent Value in 2025 NFL Draft

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 13 games of Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Rajvir Bal Compares Jaxson Dart to Brett Favre

Reading Time: 4 minutesWatch six games of Ole Miss QB Jaxson Dart during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Ashton Jeanty Draws Hall of Fame Grade in 2025 NFL Draft

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty in 13 games during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Jalen Milroe: More Than Just a Football Player

Reading Time: 3 minutesFirst Round Mock's Victoria Jonach looks into Jalen Milroe's recent "LANK" episode.

Read More...

Abdul Carter Best Defensive Player in 2025 NFL Draft

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 15 games of Penn State EDGE rusher Abdul Carter from the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Rajvir Bal Puts First Round Grade on QB Kyle McCord

Reading Time: 4 minutesWatch four games of Syracuse QB Kyle McCord during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Former NFL Scout Loves Wide Receiver Travis Hunter

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 13 games of wide receiver/cornerback Travis Hunter at Colorado in 2024 embedded into this article.

Read More...

How NIL is Allowing Quinn Ewers to Give Back to His Mom

Reading Time: 2 minutesFirst Round Mock's Victoria Jonach explores Quinn Ewers' recent claim about NIL.

Read More...

Tyler Warren is Travis Kelce 2.0

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 14 games of Penn State tight end Tyler Warren from the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...