BATON ROUGE, LA - NOVEMBER 14: Arch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns calls a play at the line against the LSU Tigers during the first half of a game at Tiger Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. (Photo by Derick Hingle/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
BATON ROUGE, LA - NOVEMBER 14: Arch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns calls a play at the line against the LSU Tigers during the first half of a game at Tiger Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. (Photo by Derick Hingle/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Arch Manning Ball Security Woes vs. No. 21 LSU

Reading Time: 3 minutes
BATON ROUGE, LA – NOVEMBER 14: Arch Manning #16 of the Texas Longhorns passes against the LSU Tigers during the first half of a game at Tiger Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. (Photo by Derick Hingle/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

I know…I know…

Everybody probably only wants to talk about how University of Texas quarterback Arch Manning threw the game-winning touchdown pass vs. LSU with six seconds left.

Everybody will probably only remember that play.

But⎯

That’s not what this is about.

It’s about how Manning looked in this game from an NFL perspective.

WATCH TEXAS VS. LSU BY CLICKING HERE

Manning didn’t heat up until 2:19 left in the game

The Longhorns scored on their opening drive, and Manning finished it off himself by taking it in from one yard out.

Outside of that?

He looked pretty ho-hum until the final drive. It was mostly short passes and runs the rest of the game.

Per Pro Football Focus (PFF):

Out of Manning’s 19 completions, 16 were nine yards or less. Eight of those were behind the line of scrimmage. Texas had 32 rushing attempts, and 12 of those rushing attempts were Manning doing the running.

Then came that final drive

Trailing 21-16 with 2:19 to play at his own 42-yard line⎯

That’s when I saw a change in Manning. That’s when he began playing with more urgency. Texas worked their way downfield. There was a have-to-have-it third-down conversion pass of his mixed in.

ESPN put up a graphic during that drive that stated Manning had six wins when he was tied or trailing in the 4th quarter.

Make it seven.

Texas 22

LSU 21

Elephant in the room

Manning vs. LSU:

  • Three interceptions
  • Five pass breakups (PBUs)

Yikes!

Yeah⎯

Not good.

Not good at all.

Positives from this game?

  • Toughness
  • Perseverance
  • Ability to pick up chunks of yardage with his legs
  • Clutch moments

Negatives from this game?

  • Operated almost exclusively out of shotgun formation (NFL quarterbacks also need to be able to take snaps under center)
  • Clapping cadence (NFL quarterbacks use a verbal cadence)
  • Didn’t look comfortable in his uniform (constantly trying to loosen up)
  • Methodical pace until the last drive
  • Exuded a lower energy level most of the game
  • Showed little to no pocket awareness (sacked 4x) and allowed himself to become overcrowded in the pocket
  • Tended to lock in with his targets
  • Threw with too much upper body (slingshot throwing motion)
  • Too reckless as a runner (absorbed too much contact)
  • Hot and cold

NFL takeaway

Manning showed a little bit of everything in this game, and he continued to show me that he has the skill set of an NFL career backup. It continues to feel like Manning trusts his legs more than his arm, and it continues to feel like his coaches would rather call run plays than pass plays.

No question⎯

His clutch gene is alluring. Thinking of what that may look like on a struggling NFL franchise is tempting. I also liked his 2.65-second time to throw in this game (PFF).

But⎯

There are just too many negatives that don’t project well to the next level, and I can’t see Manning being a successful NFL starting quarterback with the kind of ball security issues he showed in this game.

Daniel Kelly is a former NFL Scout with the New York Jets. He was hired on the regime which featured Bill Parcells, Bill Belichick, Scott Pioli, Mike Tannenbaum, and Dick Haley. He is currently the Editor-in-Chief for First Round Mock, and has written for Sports Illustrated (Lions, Jets, and 49ers), NFL Draft Diamonds, and Yardbarker, as well as appearing as a guest on ESPN Radio, Fox Sports Radio, and Fearless with Jason Whitlock. Featured in USA Today. For more information, visit whateverittakesbook.com. Follow on Twitter @firstroundmock.

Featured Articles

Hurricanes’ Rueben Bain Jr. Gets Into the Quarterback’s Head

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch nine games of University of Miami defender Rueben Bain Jr. during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Ohio State Linebacker Arvell Reese Disappointing 2024 Game Film

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 16 games of Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

New Indiana QB Fernando Mendoza Too Inconsistent at CAL

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 11 games of Indiana transfer QB Fernando Mendoza from the 2024 season when he played for CAL embedded into this article.

Read More...

Ty Simpson Progressed on his 2022, 2023, and 2024 Game Film

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson in 15 games over the span of the 2022, 2023 and 2024 seasons embedded into this article.

Read More...

Ohio State Safety Caleb Downs has Once-in-a-Lifetime Speed

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 16 games of Ohio State safety Caleb Downs during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

QB Dante Moore Has Tunnel Vision

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch QB Dante Moore in 13 games during the 2023 and 2024 seasons when he played for UCLA and Oregon embedded into this article.

Read More...

Wide Receiver Jordyn Tyson Keeps the Offense Moving

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 12 games of ASU wide receiver Jordyn Tyson during the 2024 season embedded in this article.

Read More...

Auburn Defender Keldric Faulk Springs Into the Pocket

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch Auburn defender Keldric Faulk in 10 games during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Utah Right Tackle Spencer Fano is Dominant

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch 12 games of Utah right tackle Spencer Fano during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...

Peter Woods Proves to be a Real Handful

Reading Time: 3 minutesWatch Clemson defensive lineman Peter Woods in 11 games during the 2024 season embedded into this article.

Read More...